Accordions · Opinion

Why the cheap vintage accordion is usually a trap (and when it isn't)

That beautiful old accordion at a bargain price is one of the most seductive and most disappointing buys in music. Here is what hides inside, and the narrow case where the bargain is real.

A vintage accordion is a romantic object: ornate, weighty, history in mother-of-pearl. And the prices on old ones can look astonishing next to a new instrument, which is exactly the problem. The cheap vintage accordion is one of the great traps in music buying, because the most important parts are hidden, perishable, and ruinously expensive to fix.

What you cannot see and cannot easily afford

An accordion is a box of reeds, leather valves, and bellows, all of which age. The leather valves dry, crack, and stop sealing; the bellows develop leaks; the reeds can corrode or fall out of tune; the wax that holds reeds can degrade. None of this is visible from the outside, and a thorough restoration by a specialist can cost more than the instrument is worth — sometimes far more. The pretty case tells you nothing about the health of the lungs inside.

The tells, before you fall in love: play every note and chord and listen for ones that are weak, slow to speak, or silent; press and pull the bellows gently and feel for leaks or notes sounding when no key is pressed; smell the inside for mould or heavy must. A vintage accordion that has not been serviced in decades is a project, not a bargain, however lovely it looks.

When the bargain is actually real

The vintage buy makes sense in two cases: when it has been recently and verifiably serviced by a known repairer (ask for the history), or when you are buying knowingly as a restoration project and have priced the work, not the instrument. A cheap, unserviced accordion bought hoping it is fine is a gamble where the house holds the reeds. A cheap one bought with eyes open about the work ahead can be a joy.

The honest advice

If you just want to learn and play, a modest, working, modern or recently-serviced instrument will frustrate you far less than a gorgeous, silent antique. Buy sound before you buy soul. The romantic vintage accordion can wait until you know enough to judge its lungs — or to love it as a project rather than expect it as a bargain.

Gear for accordions

More Accordions guides

GuideAccordion Collecting: Piano vs Button, Italian Makers Excelsior and Scanda…How to evaluate vintage accordions: piano vs button systems, Italian maker quality tiers, hand-made vs machine reed…